Search This Blog

Showing posts with label ACA. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ACA. Show all posts

Tuesday, July 3, 2012

Medicaid Expansion - Will your state be In or Out

Healthcare blog at the TheHill.com has published an interesting article - "Fifteen governors reject or leaning against expanded Medicaid program". This brings a very valid point, if the congress passed a law that has an option to opt out for the state how will the overall effort be effected, since we are talking about a federal law implementation. 

As much as I would like to stay out of politics, this is one topic where I simply cannot refrain myself from commenting. The implementation and acceptance of the Medicaid expansion can only work if it is implemented across all of the states, with the affordable option for healthcare insurance be available anywhere in the country. Should a state choose not to participate it may have far beyond reach implications on the migration of the population from one state to another.
At least 15 governors have indicated they will not participate in the expansion of Medicaid under the healthcare law, striking a blow to President Obama’s promise of broader insurance coverage.

Before Thursday’s Supreme Court ruling, states had the option of either increasing their Medicaid rolls or being penalized by the federal government. The high court struck down that offer as unconstitutional.


“You can make the political call real quick, but the actual decision is a complicated one,” said Matt Salo of the National Association of Medicaid Directors. “Governors are going to be looking at the numbers and asking: Does this make sense for us?”
Seven states with Republican governors have given a flat “no” to the Medicaid expansion since the Supreme Court ruling, according to reports and press statements.
States that will decline to participate include Florida, where Gov. Rick Scott (R) turned his opposition to the law into a political career, and Louisiana, where Gov. Bobby Jindal (R) has vowed to help elect Mitt Romney as president in order to repeal it.

In eight other states — seven with GOP governors — the Medicaid expansion seems unlikely, given comments from governors and their offices.

Texas Gov. Rick Perry (R) “has no interest in fast-tracking any portion of this bankrupting and overreaching legislation,” spokeswoman Lucy Nashed said in a statement Monday. “We will continue to call for the full repeal of the bill.”

Virginia Gov. Bob McDonnell (R), considered a contender to be Romney’s vice-presidential nominee, said his focus is on November. 
Some consider the expansion as "budget-busting":

“The only way to stop Barack Obama’s budget-busting healthcare takeover is by electing a new president,” McDonnell said in a statement following the court’s decision.
Interestingly enough, a lot of states already working on the Medicaid redesign and expansion even without a Federal mandate. But that doesn't apply to all.

Some states haven't made a decision as of yet, whether they will or won't participate in the expansion of the program.  
New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie (R), also the subject of VP speculation, has not announced what his state will do. His political position is trickier, since he leads a blue state where there is more support for the healthcare law.

In its original form, the Affordable Care Act would have pulled all federal funds for state Medicaid programs that did not expand as the law intended.

Chief Justice John Roberts strongly criticized that approach in his opinion for the majority.
“The financial ‘inducement’ Congress has chosen is much more than ‘relatively mild encouragement’ ” to expand Medicaid, Roberts wrote. “It is a gun to the head.”

Past estimates have found that, as designed, the law’s expansion would have provided healthcare access to an additional 17 million low-income Americans.

“States have a lot to consider,” said Robin Rudowitz with the Kaiser Commission on Medicaid and the Uninsured. “That is a lot of federal money sitting on the table.”

Alan Weil with the National Academy for State Health Policy said states that do not comply could raise the ire of some in Congress.

“If states turn down that offer, it leaves a lot of people uninsured. If we end up in that place, a lot of people in Congress are going to say that is a problem,” he said.

Several Democrats have expressed confidence that the bill’s intention to expand healthcare coverage can still be fulfilled.

Peter Orszag, who led the White House budget office during the healthcare debate and had a major role in shaping the legislation, said states might come around eventually.

He said the law’s coverage expansion would be significantly undercut if a large number of states opt out.

“There may be significant gaps that open up, and that would be unfortunate,” he said, noting that more than half of the coverage expansion was set to come through Medicaid.

But Orszag said there is plenty of precedent for states to expand their Medicaid programs when they don’t have to. About 60 percent of current Medicaid spending goes toward people or benefits that are not mandated by federal law, he said. States decide to provide those optional benefits because the federal government bears most of the cost — and it would cover an even bigger share of the Affordable Care Act’s expansion.

The federal government will cover the entire cost of the expansion for a few years. Its share begins to drop after that, but Orszag said it won’t fall far enough to be a bad deal for states.
“A 90 percent subsidy rate is going to be hard to resist,” Orszag said Monday on a conference call organized by Foreign Affairs magazine.
— Sam Baker, Lydia Nuzum and Gunnar Sidak contributed to this report.
You can find original article along with the list of states that already decided on their participation/non-participation here

Affordable Care Act - Let's Look Inside

In a very descriptive article posted by the ModernHealthcare.com Joe Carlos has explained the ruling.

With the new ruling in place those that will not have/purchase health insurance will be subjected to additional taxes.  
The court ruled that Congress has the power to compel individuals to purchase insurance as a tax on people who do not have health insurance.
...the court ruled that Congress has the power to compel individuals to purchase insurance as a tax on people who do not have health insurance.
The important piece of information is that with this legislation passed the number of affordable options to purchase an insurance coverage will hopefully increase. As part of the overall process to better healthcare NY State is already working through a Medicaid redesign program. The ultimate objective is of course to prevent illness from developing and spreading by implementing more of preventive measures. Annual visits as well as other precautions can result in decreased number of admissions into the hospital and shorter waiting time in the Emergency room. Having an insurance coverage enables every one of us as a patient to take care of our health not in the time of crises but continuously by maintaining a healthy lifestyle.
The landmark decisions end two years of legal uncertainty and clear the way for full implementation of the 906-page law. Doing so includes establishing insurance exchanges in each state, prohibiting insurance companies from discriminating against the sick, and requiring nearly all Americans to prove on their income taxes that they carry health insurance starting in 2014.

"Today's historic decision lifts a heavy burden from millions of Americans who need access to health coverage. The promise of coverage can now become a reality,” said American Hospital Association President and CEO Richard Umbdenstock in a statement. “The decision means that hospitals now have much-needed clarity to continue on their path toward transformation.”

The insurance industry's national interest group, America's Health Insurance Plans, released a statement reiterating its position that “universal coverage” was essential to avoiding significant increases in cost and decreases in choices for health insurance.
 There is a slight downside of course, as per Karen Ignagni, but with the absence of the pre-existing condition clause alone the disruption of coverage can be reinstated.
“The law expands coverage to millions of Americans, a goal health plans have long supported,” AHIP President and CEO Karen Ignagni said in a statement, “but major provisions, such as the premium tax, will have the unintended consequences of raising costs and disrupting coverage unless they are addressed.”

The court, however, did strike down part of the reform law's mandated expansion of Medicaid. Congress had aimed to expand the insurance program for the poor by at least 16 million people, but the court ruled that Congress did not have the power to cut off Medicaid funding for states that refused to comply with the law's eligibility rules.

The law said that states "must either accept a basic change in the nature of Medicaid or risk losing all Medicaid funding," Roberts wrote. "The remedy for that constitutional violation is to preclude the federal government from imposing such a sanction … As a practical matter that means states may now choose to reject the expansion; that is the whole point. But that doesn't mean all or even any will.”
For original Article - click here

To download 193 page opinion and dissent document (PDF) produced by the Congress - click here